Not long ago, school librarian Meredith Inkeles (@KRESLibrary)
tweeted the following:
After sharing Sibert Award-winning Summertime Sleepers by Melissa Stewart and Sarah S. Brannen with 3rd graders, they had some amazing questions
about the mangrove killifish & the pixie frog. I think we have some
research to do!
A few minutes later, she followed up with a list of their questions:
Mangrove killifish questions:
—How can fish live in a log?
—How can they stay alive that long (for several weeks or even months)?
—How can they come on land?
—How do they not die?
—How can they sleep in a log?
Most asked pixie frog questions:
—Why does it eat the cocoon
—What does the cocoon taste like?
These are all excellent questions, but I kind of fell in
love with that last one. Probably because it made me ask some questions of my
own:
—Do frogs have taste buds?
—Do they experience taste the same way
animals do?
So I tweeted back:
You might ask students if they think frogs taste
things in the same way we do. Then read then They All Saw a Cat by @brendanwenzel
Turns out that idea was a success. The next week, Meredith
responded:
It was the BEST discussion on perspective and 5 senses,
bringing it back to taste! Now, we research.
This was music to my ears because I have no doubt those
curious kids were truly motivated to explore and discover.
That made me wonder . . . what would they learn about how frogs
experience the world? And how would they share their new-found knowledge?
These questions bring to mind a study I once heard Bill
Badders, Past President of the National Science Teaching Association, cite:
“Scientists spend 60-70 percent of their time reading, writing, and communicating.
Literacy is an authentic part of science.”
Amen
to that.
There’s
no doubt in my mind that these third graders are scientists—people who ask questions and then seek out the answers. A scientist’s quest can take many
forms, from conducting experiments to re-examining long-forgotten museum
specimens to reading books and articles written at the third-grade level.
Look out
world . . . there’s no stopping these students!
Most Popular Posts
Resignation
Re-thinking “E” Is for Everyone
We Need Diverse Nonfiction
The 5 Kinds of Nonfiction
Behind the Books: Does Story Appeal to Everyone?
10 STEM Picture Books
Nonfiction Authors Dig Deep by Melissa Stewart
Nonfiction Authors Dig Deep by Deborah Heiligman
Is It Fiction or Nonfiction? A Twitterchat
5 Kinds of Nonfiction, Book Lists
Topics
3 Responses
what great questions!
Love this – research that means something to them!
You have the best interactions with educators and kids!